Birbhum Family Deportation — The alleged deportation of a Bengali-speaking family from Birbhum, West Bengal, to Bangladesh by Delhi authorities has triggered legal scrutiny and a broader debate on citizenship verification, migrant rights, and due process in India. The incident has reached the Calcutta High Court, which is now closely examining whether proper legal procedures were followed and whether the family, all Indian citizens according to the petitioner, were wrongfully deported.
Birbhum Family Deportation: Background of the Case
The deported family includes Danish Sheikh, his pregnant wife Sunali Khatun, and their minor son. All three were reportedly picked up by the Delhi Police in the Rohini area on June 18. They were taken to the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO), where they were questioned and, according to legal filings, asked to prove their nationality. Despite allegedly presenting valid Indian documents — including Aadhaar, voter ID cards, and land records — they were deported to Bangladesh on June 26.
Their disappearance raised concern among family members in West Bengal, who eventually filed a habeas corpus petition in the Calcutta High Court seeking accountability and legal redress.
Calcutta High Court’s Intervention
A Division Bench comprising Justices Tapabrata Chakraborty and Reetobroto Kumar Mitra has directed the central government, the governments of West Bengal and Delhi, and the FRRO to file affidavits explaining:
- The basis of the family’s detention
- The method of nationality verification used
- Whether due legal process, including tribunal review, was followed
- Whether deporting Indian citizens, if proven, was a violation of fundamental rights
The Bench expressed concern about a sudden increase in the number of Bengali-speaking individuals being detained and deported in June and asked if linguistic profiling played a role in these actions.
The Court has set a deadline of July 28 for the Centre to file its response, while the West Bengal government must submit its affidavit by August 4. The case is scheduled for a further hearing on August 6.
Larger Pattern of Detentions and Deportations
The incident is not isolated. In recent months, there have been several reported cases of Bengali-speaking individuals being detained in other parts of the country — including Odisha, Karnataka, and Delhi — on suspicion of being illegal Bangladeshi immigrants. Many of those affected had Indian documents, raising concerns of profiling and wrongful deportation without judicial oversight.
In several such cases, there have been complaints that individuals were deported or handed over to border forces without being given a chance to prove their identity before a tribunal, which is a legal requirement under the Foreigners Act.
Reactions from Authorities and Civil Society
The incident has sparked political outrage in West Bengal. Samirul Islam, the Chairman of the West Bengal Migrant Workers’ Welfare Board, alleged that the family’s deportation was not only unlawful but amounted to a violation of constitutional protections against discrimination and arbitrary detention.
“There is no rule in this country that says a Bengali-speaking person cannot live in another state,” he stated. “These are citizens of India. Their only crime is that they speak Bengali.”
The West Bengal government is also expected to provide data on other such incidents and is in discussions with central authorities to ensure that due process is followed in any similar cases moving forward.
Legal Implications
This case has brought to light several important constitutional and legal concerns:
- Article 14: The Right to Equality — If linguistic profiling is proven, it could amount to discrimination.
- Article 21: The Right to Life and Personal Liberty — Any detention or deportation without proper legal procedure violates this right.
- Foreigners Act, 1946: Mandates that cases of suspected illegal immigrants must be placed before a Foreigners Tribunal, allowing the person to defend their claim to Indian citizenship.
By allegedly bypassing the tribunal process, authorities may have violated these legal standards.
The Way Forward
The Calcutta High Court’s directive could set an important precedent in clarifying:
- How state and central agencies should verify nationality
- What safeguards must be in place to prevent wrongful detention
- The role of linguistic identity in migration-related enforcement actions
As more such cases come to light, the issue is no longer just about one family from Birbhum — it reflects a broader tension between national security measures and civil liberties, particularly for migrant laborers from eastern India who frequently travel across states for work.
Official External Resources
- Calcutta High Court
- Ministry of Home Affairs – Foreigners Division
- Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO)
- Constitution of India – Article 14 (Equality Before Law)
Also read: Home | Channel 6 Network – Latest News, Breaking Updates: Politics, Business, Tech & More
