SC Rejects Review Pleas on 25,000: In a landmark judgment that has sent shockwaves across West Bengal’s education sector, the Supreme Court on Friday dismissed review petitions challenging its earlier order that scrapped over 25,000 school jobs in the state. The apex court reaffirmed that the recruitment process for teachers and non-teaching staff was “vitiated and tainted beyond redemption,” making it impossible to salvage even a single appointment without undermining the integrity of the education system.
The petitions had been filed on behalf of candidates who claimed they were “untainted” and had secured their positions purely on merit. However, the court observed that the scale of irregularities in the School Service Commission (SSC) recruitment scam was so extensive that distinguishing genuine candidates from those who benefited from manipulation was not practically feasible.
Background of the SSC Scam
The controversy dates back to 2014–2016 recruitment cycles when the West Bengal School Service Commission conducted examinations to fill thousands of vacancies in government-aided schools. Allegations soon emerged of massive corruption involving inflated marks, manipulation of Optical Mark Recognition (OMR) sheets, and the illegal appointment of candidates outside the merit list.
Investigations by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and the Enforcement Directorate (ED) unearthed staggering irregularities. Several political figures, including former education minister Partha Chatterjee, were arrested, along with middlemen accused of orchestrating the scam. Crores of rupees in cash were recovered during raids, making headlines across the nation.
For years, thousands of genuine aspirants fought legal battles, claiming their rightful opportunities had been stolen. Meanwhile, those who had secured jobs amid the irregularities continued teaching, creating an environment of deep mistrust within schools.
The Supreme Court’s Firm Stand
The Supreme Court’s dismissal of the review petitions reflects its determination to uphold transparency and accountability in public recruitment. The bench categorically stated that while it empathized with candidates who may have been innocent, allowing their appointments to continue would only perpetuate an unfair system.
“The recruitment was not just irregular but fundamentally compromised. The sanctity of the process stands destroyed. We cannot allow tainted appointments to exist in public education institutions,” the court observed.
The ruling paves the way for fresh recruitment in West Bengal schools. However, it also raises pressing questions about the fate of thousands of families who will now lose livelihoods, and about how the state government will manage the immediate shortfall of teaching staff.
SC Rejects Review Pleas on 25,000: Political Fallout
The judgment is expected to have major political repercussions in Bengal, especially with the opposition parties sharpening their attacks on the ruling Trinamool Congress (TMC).
- The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has accused the state government of institutionalizing corruption and exploiting unemployed youth.
- The Left Front and the Congress echoed similar sentiments, calling for immediate resignation of senior leaders linked to the scam.
- Meanwhile, the TMC leadership has maintained that the government will comply with the SC’s directives but has urged the Centre to expedite fresh recruitment to prevent a “collapse of the school education system.”
Impact on Teachers and Students
The cancellation of 25,000 jobs is not just a legal or political matter—it has significant consequences for schools across Bengal. Many institutions are already facing a shortage of qualified staff. The sudden removal of such a large number of teachers and non-teaching staff will create immediate disruptions in classrooms, affecting lakhs of students.
At the same time, education experts have welcomed the judgment, stating that it will restore faith in public recruitment and give deserving aspirants a fair chance. “If corruption goes unchecked, generations of students will suffer. This was a necessary step, however painful it may seem,” said a Kolkata-based educationist.
Way Forward
The West Bengal government is now under pressure to announce a transparent, technology-driven recruitment process that eliminates scope for manipulation. Experts have suggested live CCTV monitoring of exam centers, centralized digital evaluation, and real-time publication of merit lists to restore credibility.
The ruling also serves as a warning to other states where recruitment scams have surfaced in the past. With the Supreme Court setting a precedent of zero tolerance, education recruitment across India may now face stricter judicial and administrative scrutiny.
External References
- Supreme Court of India
- Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)
- Enforcement Directorate (ED)
- West Bengal School Service Commission
Also read: Home | Channel 6 Network – Latest News, Breaking Updates: Politics, Business, Tech & More
