Kolkata Study Exposes Limits of BMI: A recent study by SSKM Hospital and Medical College, Kolkata, has sparked nationwide attention after revealing a concerning health paradox: nearly half of young Indian women with a so-called ‘normal’ Body Mass Index (BMI) were still at significant risk of developing Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS).
This finding challenges long-held assumptions in healthcare that BMI alone is an adequate measure for obesity or metabolic disorders. For decades, BMI has been considered the “gold standard” for assessing body fat and classifying individuals as underweight, normal, overweight, or obese. But for Indian women, especially the younger generation, the research shows that BMI hides more than it reveals.
Why BMI is Failing Indian Women
BMI was developed almost two centuries ago by Belgian mathematician Adolphe Quetelet, and it was never intended as a medical diagnostic tool. It merely divides a person’s weight by their height squared. While easy to calculate, it tells us nothing about fat distribution, hormonal balance, or metabolic activity—all of which are crucial in conditions like PCOS.
For Indian women, this limitation becomes even more pronounced. Studies over the past decade have consistently shown that South Asians carry higher levels of abdominal fat and are more prone to insulin resistance at lower BMIs compared to Europeans or Americans. In simple terms, an Indian woman with a BMI of 22 may carry the same risk for diabetes or PCOS as a Western woman with a BMI of 27.
The SSKM study underscores this reality: BMI failed to detect central obesity and hidden insulin resistance—two of the strongest risk factors for PCOS.
Understanding PCOS and Its Wider Implications
Polycystic Ovary Syndrome is one of the most common hormonal disorders affecting women of reproductive age. It is characterized by irregular periods, ovarian cysts, hormonal imbalance, excessive hair growth, acne, weight gain, and in some cases, infertility.
But the risks go beyond reproductive health. Women with PCOS face higher chances of developing:
- Type 2 diabetes
- Cardiovascular diseases
- Hypertension
- Endometrial cancer
The hidden nature of PCOS, combined with India’s reliance on BMI as the primary obesity measure, means thousands of young women may remain undiagnosed until complications surface.
Alternative Tools: Beyond BMI
The Kolkata study suggests more accurate indicators, including:
- Waist-to-Height Ratio (WHtR): A simple calculation dividing waist circumference by height. If the ratio is above 0.5, it signals unhealthy fat distribution and risk of metabolic disease.
- Neck Circumference (NC): Emerging as a reliable predictor of insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome.
- Waist Circumference (WC): Directly measures central fat—often a better indicator of health risk than BMI.
- Body Composition Analysis: Advanced tools like DEXA scans can differentiate between muscle, fat, and visceral fat.
These alternatives may sound technical, but they are inexpensive, easy to measure, and can be introduced in clinics and schools across India.
Lean PCOS: The Hidden Danger
One of the most alarming aspects highlighted by SSKM researchers is the prevalence of “lean PCOS.” These are women who look slim, have a normal BMI, but still suffer from irregular cycles, cystic ovaries, and high insulin resistance.
Such women are often ignored or told they are “healthy” because their BMI does not raise red flags. By the time symptoms worsen—often in their late 20s or early 30s—diagnosis is delayed, and fertility challenges may already have set in.
Cultural and Lifestyle Factors
Indian women today are navigating rapid lifestyle changes—sedentary jobs, processed diets, irregular sleep, and high stress levels—all of which contribute to hormonal imbalance. Yet, many are judged solely by external appearance.
- A young professional in Kolkata may appear “fit” because she is not overweight, but long hours at a desk, high sugar intake, and poor exercise routines can still trigger PCOS.
- In smaller towns, lack of awareness about PCOS leads many women to dismiss irregular periods or acne as “normal,” missing early intervention opportunities.
The mismatch between BMI numbers and actual health reality deepens these cultural blind spots.
Global Shift: BMI Losing Its Grip
Globally, there is growing recognition that BMI is outdated. The World Health Organization (WHO) has acknowledged its limitations, especially for Asian populations. In the US and UK, healthcare practitioners are increasingly adopting waist-to-height ratio and metabolic health indicators alongside BMI.
The Indian medical community, however, continues to rely heavily on BMI for screening, government health surveys, and even school health checks. The SSKM study may become the much-needed wake-up call for a paradigm shift.
Policy Implications and Public Health
If BMI continues to be the dominant metric, India risks under-diagnosing a large segment of its population—especially women. This could lead to:
- Higher rates of undetected PCOS
- Escalating cases of infertility
- Rising healthcare costs due to diabetes and cardiovascular complications
Experts argue that government health programs, including those under the National Health Mission, should integrate waist measurements and WHtR in their protocols. Awareness campaigns in schools and colleges could also help young women recognize early symptoms and seek timely medical advice.
A Call for Women-Centric Healthcare
Women’s health in India has often been overshadowed by broader concerns like maternal mortality or child health. Conditions like PCOS, which affect quality of life, fertility, and long-term well-being, deserve dedicated policy focus.
The SSKM study highlights not just a scientific flaw in BMI, but also a gendered health gap—where young women are at risk of being ignored because the most commonly used tool fails them.
Kolkata Study Exposes Limits of BMI: What Women Can Do
Until systemic changes are implemented, women can take proactive steps:
- Track waist circumference regularly, not just weight.
- Consult doctors if they face irregular cycles, excessive hair growth, or sudden weight gain, even if BMI looks normal.
- Incorporate lifestyle changes—balanced diet, regular physical activity, and stress management.
- Advocate for broader health screenings in workplaces, schools, and communities.
External Resources for Further Reading
- Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS) Overview – Causes, symptoms, and treatment approaches.
🔗 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycystic_ovary_syndrome - Limitations of Body Mass Index – History, criticisms, and ethnic differences in BMI applicability.
🔗 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index - Waist-to-Height Ratio as a Better Health Indicator – Medical research discussing WHtR vs BMI.
🔗 https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33400176/ - Insulin Resistance and PCOS – How insulin metabolism affects women with PCOS.
🔗 https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8984569/ - Meta-analysis on Neck Circumference and Metabolic Syndrome in PCOS
🔗 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41366-025-01753-1
Also read: Home | Channel 6 Network – Latest News, Breaking Updates: Politics, Business, Tech & More
