The Malda civic volunteer suspension has become a flashpoint in Bengal’s pre‑election politics. On December 22, 2025, the Janata Unnayan Party (JUP), newly floated by suspended Trinamool MLA Humayun Kabir, announced Mustara Bibi as its prospective candidate from the Baishnabnagar Assembly constituency in Malda. Hours later, Mustara was suspended from her civic volunteer job, sparking allegations of political vendetta and raising questions about the neutrality of state institutions.
2. Background of the Case
- Mustara Bibi, originally from Kaleswar in Birbhum, currently resides in Binnagar‑I panchayat, Baishnabnagar with her husband Kurban Ansari, who heads a voluntary organization.
- Kurban was once associated with Trinamool but later became politically inactive.
- On December 22, Kabir formally announced the launch of JUP and simultaneously declared Mustara’s candidature.
- That same day, she received suspension orders from her civic volunteer position.
3. Mustara’s Response
- Mustara told media: “I have no regret about being dropped from service. I am ready to contest the election for the JUP, and I am confident of winning the Assembly seat.”
- She alleged her suspension was directly linked to her political association with JUP.
- She emphasized that she did not wish to return to service, choosing instead to focus on her political career.
4. Police and Administrative Position
- Malda Superintendent of Police Avijit Banerjee declined to comment.
- Police sources claimed Mustara was irregular in her duties.
- They also argued that civic volunteers are not permitted to engage directly in political activities.
- This justification has been contested by opposition voices who see it as selective enforcement.
5. Malda Civic Volunteer Suspension: Political Fallout
- Trinamool Congress (TMC): District spokesperson Ashis Kundu dismissed Kabir as an “eccentric politician” and said JUP candidates would secure fewer votes than NOTA.
- BJP: District president Ajay Ganguly downplayed JUP’s significance, alleging the party was indirectly helping TMC.
- Civil society: Raised concerns about the shrinking space for political dissent and the vulnerability of grassroots workers.
6. Governance Challenges
The suspension reflects:
- Conflict between state employment and political participation.
- Weak safeguards for civic volunteers against arbitrary action.
- Polarization of institutions in Bengal’s political climate.
- Fragile democratic space for new parties like JUP.
7. Government External Links for Assistance
- Election Commission of India: https://eci.gov.in
- West Bengal Police: https://wbpolice.gov.in
- Government of West Bengal: https://wb.gov.in
- Supreme Court of India: https://main.sci.gov.in
8. Historical Context of Political Suspensions in Bengal
- 2011 onwards: Multiple civic volunteers and contractual staff faced suspension for alleged political activity.
- 2019 Lok Sabha elections: Allegations of bias in administrative action against opposition supporters.
- 2021 Assembly elections: Several grassroots workers claimed harassment for political affiliations.
- The 2025 Malda case continues this trend, highlighting the intersection of employment and political rights.
9. Community Impact
- Local residents expressed sympathy for Mustara, seeing her as a symbol of grassroots resilience.
- Her suspension has created fear among other civic volunteers considering political participation.
- The incident has energized JUP supporters, who view it as proof of establishment resistance.
10. Global Comparisons
Similar disputes occur worldwide:
- Turkey: Civil servants suspended for alleged political affiliations.
- Egypt: Public employees barred from contesting elections.
- USA: Strict rules on government employees engaging in partisan politics (Hatch Act).
The Malda case mirrors these global struggles where employment rules collide with democratic participation rights.
11. Governance Lessons
The Malda suspension teaches:
- Clear legal frameworks are needed for civic volunteers’ political rights.
- Independent oversight can prevent arbitrary suspensions.
- Community engagement strengthens trust in institutions.
- Balance between neutrality and rights is essential in governance.
12. Future Outlook – Democracy in Bengal
India must move towards:
- Codified rules on political participation for contractual staff.
- Judicial safeguards against politically motivated suspensions.
- Awareness campaigns to protect grassroots workers’ rights.
- Inclusive politics that allows new parties like JUP to compete fairly.
13. Conclusion
The Malda civic volunteer suspension of Mustara Bibi after her nomination as JUP candidate underscores the fragility of democratic space in Bengal. While police cite irregularity and rules against political activity, the timing of her suspension raises serious questions. For Bengal, the challenge is to ensure that employment rules do not become tools of political vendetta, and that democracy remains open to new voices.
Also read: Home | Channel 6 Network – Latest News, Breaking Updates: Politics, Business, Tech & More
