Budge Budge Woman Bengali Language: A woman from Budge Budge, West Bengal, has come forward with a troubling account of being interrogated by Mumbai Police officers allegedly because she was speaking in Bengali while on a visit to the city. The incident, which has quickly gained attention on social media, has once again raised questions about linguistic prejudice, identity politics, and the lived experiences of migrants in India’s metropolitan hubs.
Budge Budge Woman Bengali Language: Incident Overview
According to the woman, who has requested anonymity for safety reasons, she was in Mumbai earlier this week visiting a friend. While speaking to her friend in Bengali in a public place, she was reportedly approached by police officers and subjected to questioning about her identity, purpose of visit, and residential status.
She alleged that the officers appeared suspicious of her solely because of her language, asking her questions unrelated to any specific incident. “I was shocked and hurt. I have travelled across India, but this is the first time I felt my mother tongue was treated as a crime,” she said.
Police Version
Mumbai Police sources have stated that the officers involved were conducting routine checks in the area following recent security alerts and that there was no intention to target any particular language group. A senior police official, however, said they would review the incident internally to ensure no bias or misconduct occurred during the questioning.
Social Media Outrage
As soon as the incident was shared online, the news sparked strong reactions from political leaders, activists, and citizens. Hashtags like #SpeakBengaliFreely and #StopLinguisticBias trended on X (formerly Twitter), with many users highlighting the need for linguistic inclusivity in a diverse nation like India.
Civil rights activists have pointed out that such incidents create an environment of alienation for non-native language speakers in certain states, discouraging cultural exchange and national unity.
Political Reactions
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee expressed concern over the alleged incident, stating, “India’s unity lies in its diversity. No citizen should be harassed for speaking in their mother tongue.” She called for a formal inquiry and urged the Maharashtra government to ensure that all languages are respected equally.
Opposition leaders in Maharashtra also weighed in. Some criticized what they called a “growing culture of suspicion” towards outsiders, while others defended the police, suggesting that the situation may have been misinterpreted.
Language and Identity in Indian Cities
The incident has rekindled discussions about the experiences of migrant communities in large Indian cities. Mumbai, often celebrated as a melting pot of cultures, has seen multiple debates over language identity — especially between Marathi-speaking locals and speakers of other languages like Hindi, Gujarati, and Bengali.
Language-based political movements have a long history in Maharashtra, with certain groups historically advocating for prioritizing Marathi in public and administrative spaces. While these movements often claim to protect local culture, critics argue that they can sometimes result in discrimination against speakers of other Indian languages.
Legal Context
Article 19 of the Indian Constitution guarantees the freedom of speech and expression, which extends to the choice of language. Additionally, Article 29 protects the rights of citizens to conserve their language, script, or culture. Legal experts suggest that if proven true, the incident could be viewed as a violation of these constitutional protections.
According to human rights lawyers, police personnel must undergo training to handle linguistic diversity sensitively, particularly in cosmopolitan areas like Mumbai.
Call for Sensitization and Policy Reform
Following the uproar, advocacy groups have renewed calls for mandatory sensitization workshops for law enforcement agencies, focusing on cultural and linguistic diversity. They also suggested establishing clear protocols to prevent discriminatory treatment based on language or ethnicity.
In response, some non-governmental organizations have pledged to provide legal aid and counseling to individuals who experience linguistic discrimination.
A Broader Pattern?
While this incident has gained visibility because of the victim’s willingness to speak out, experts say many such cases go unreported. Migrant workers and students from states like West Bengal, Bihar, and the Northeast often recount experiences of subtle bias or direct hostility when using their native languages in other parts of India.
A 2023 study by the Centre for the Study of Developing Societies (CSDS) noted that linguistic prejudice remains a significant challenge to India’s pluralism, with 37% of surveyed migrants reporting at least one instance of being mocked or questioned for their language.
Looking Ahead
The Budge Budge woman says she will lodge a formal complaint if the police department does not acknowledge the incident and offer an apology. She hopes that by speaking up, others facing similar experiences will feel empowered to raise their voices.
Meanwhile, social media continues to serve as a battleground for competing narratives — with some framing the event as an isolated misunderstanding, while others see it as symptomatic of deeper systemic issues in India’s approach to language diversity.
External References:
- Government of India: Official Languages Policy
- Article 19 & Article 29 – Constitution of India
- Centre for the Study of Developing Societies – Research on Linguistic Diversity
Also read: Home | Channel 6 Network – Latest News, Breaking Updates: Politics, Business, Tech & More
