Damodar Valley Corporation Flood Controversy: What should have been a moment of joy and spiritual reflection during Durga Puja turned grim across parts of southern Bengal as thousands of residents found themselves battling rising waters.
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has accused the Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC)—a central government agency—of discharging massive volumes of water from Maithon and Panchet dams without prior intimation to the state government.
The Chief Minister labeled the move as “anti-Bengal” and a “manufactured flood,” asserting that the sudden release of over 1.5 lakh cusecs of water inundated several low-lying areas, leaving citizens stranded during the festive week.
While DVC defended the release citing reservoir safety and heavy inflows from Jharkhand, the episode has reignited a long-standing state-centre conflict over flood management, coordination, and accountability in the Damodar Valley basin.
For institutional reference: Damodar Valley Corporation (Official Portal) | Ministry of Jal Shakti – Department of Water Resources
The Flashpoint: Bengal’s Chief Minister vs DVC
Mamata Banerjee’s Allegation
Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee strongly condemned the DVC’s actions during a high-level review meeting. She said:
“Releasing water during Durga Puja, without informing us, is not an accident—it’s an act of negligence that endangers human lives and disrespects Bengal’s traditions.”
She further alleged that 1.5 lakh cusecs of water were released cumulatively into the Damodar River system over a 24-hour period, causing rivers to swell in Howrah, Hooghly, East Burdwan, and Bankura districts.
The state government stated that no formal communication or advance warning was issued to Bengal’s Irrigation Department or the State Disaster Management Authority (SDMA) before the water was discharged.
Official Disaster Management updates can be found on the West Bengal Disaster Management & Civil Defence Department website.
DVC’s Defence: “Dam Safety and Inflow Compulsion”
In its response, the Damodar Valley Corporation clarified that the discharge was carried out according to standard safety protocols, as heavy rainfall in Jharkhand catchment areas caused a sharp rise in inflows into Maithon and Panchet reservoirs.
The DVC maintained that it had shared alerts with concerned departments, including Bengal’s irrigation officials, citing that reservoir levels had reached thresholds requiring immediate regulation.
Officials stated that both hydrological necessity and structural safety guided the discharge decision. The release was, they argued, essential to prevent dam overtopping and maintain operational integrity.
For technical details on dam safety and reservoir protocols: Central Water Commission – Flood Forecasting and Reservoir Operations
Hydrological and Administrative Background
The Damodar Valley Basin: India’s First Multi-Purpose River Project
The Damodar Valley Project, often called India’s first river valley initiative post-Independence, was modeled after the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) in the United States. Encompassing Jharkhand and West Bengal, the project was designed to provide flood control, irrigation, and power generation.
Key dams like Maithon, Panchet, Konar, and Tilaiya were constructed to regulate the Damodar River, once known as the “Sorrow of Bengal.” Over the decades, however, rapid urbanization, siltation, and mismanagement have undermined its flood-mitigation goals.
The Damodar Valley Reservoir Regulation Committee (DVRRC)
Operational coordination between DVC and the states of Jharkhand and West Bengal falls under the DVRRC, chaired by the Central Water Commission (CWC). The committee determines release schedules and safety thresholds.
Bengal’s government argues that DVC violated DVRRC norms by failing to consult or inform state officials before opening sluice gates.
The Aftermath: Flood-Like Conditions in South Bengal
Affected Districts
The water discharge caused river levels to surge across:
- East Burdwan
- Hooghly
- Howrah
- Bankura
- Paschim Medinipur
Reports indicated that low-lying farmlands and riverbank settlements were partially inundated, disrupting transport routes and damaging standing crops.
The state’s Irrigation Department and Disaster Management Authority deployed rescue teams, relief camps, and sandbag reinforcements near embankments along the Damodar and Mundeswari rivers.
Official flood bulletins: Central Water Commission – Flood Monitoring
Historical Pattern of Dispute Between State and DVC
The tension between the West Bengal government and DVC is not new. Over the last decade, similar accusations have arisen almost annually during the monsoon or festive seasons.
- 2015–2017: Bengal accused DVC of discharging excess water from Maithon Dam without coordination, causing widespread flooding in Burdwan.
- 2020: The Chief Minister alleged that DVC ignored state alerts during heavy rainfall.
- 2023: DVC defended large releases, citing safety measures after Jharkhand received record rain.
Each episode has deepened mistrust, exposing the lack of a transparent inter-state communication mechanism for real-time reservoir management.
Expert Opinion: The Science Behind Sudden Releases
Hydrologists argue that while dam releases are technically necessary during heavy inflows, they must be staggered and communicated in advance. Sudden discharges can raise river levels drastically, leaving downstream regions unprepared.
Dr. Ananya Majumdar, a water resource expert at Jadavpur University, explains:
“The DVC operates across two states, and rainfall patterns vary. What seems manageable upstream can trigger disasters downstream if inter-agency alerts are delayed even by hours.”
Experts have also highlighted siltation in dam reservoirs as a major concern. Sediment accumulation reduces water storage capacity, forcing higher discharges during moderate rainfall.
Political Fallout: Centre–State War of Words
The incident escalated into a political confrontation between Trinamool Congress (TMC) and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).
Mamata Banerjee accused the Centre of “weaponizing federal institutions” to create crises in Bengal. She demanded a formal apology and compensation for affected families.
The BJP’s state leadership, however, countered that the Chief Minister was shifting blame from the state’s poor flood-preparedness measures.
The Centre reportedly requested a technical report from DVC to verify claims of irregular discharge, but no official statement had been released at the time of writing.
For federal coordination frameworks: Ministry of Home Affairs – Disaster Management Division
Damodar Valley Corporation Flood Controversy: Impact on Agriculture and Livelihoods
Agricultural Losses
The unseasonal flooding has jeopardized thousands of hectares of paddy fields nearing harvest in Hooghly and Burdwan. Farmers reported crop submergence lasting over 48 hours, which could cause irreversible damage to yield.
Livelihood Disruption
Small traders, ferry operators, and transport workers also faced severe losses as river crossings and rural routes were shut down. Many families were temporarily displaced, seeking shelter in higher areas or makeshift relief camps.
The State Agriculture Department has begun preliminary damage assessment and compensation planning.
Official agricultural relief schemes: Government of West Bengal – Agriculture Department
Damodar Valley Corporation Flood Controversy: Environmental and Structural Concerns
Environmental scientists warn that unregulated water management in the Damodar basin has long-term implications for ecology, river morphology, and groundwater stability.
The accumulation of silt, loss of river depth, and encroachment on floodplains have drastically reduced the river’s carrying capacity. Periodic desiltation, once a regular part of DVC’s operation schedule, has allegedly fallen behind since the mid-2000s.
The Chief Minister demanded that DVC immediately undertake a comprehensive dredging and desiltation plan to restore capacity and prevent recurring floods.
For dredging policies and guidelines: Ministry of Jal Shakti – National Water Mission
Administrative Response: Bengal’s Counter-Measures
In the wake of the crisis, the Bengal government:
- Activated a 24-hour control room under the Disaster Management Department.
- Directed all District Magistrates to deploy Quick Response Teams (QRTs) in vulnerable areas.
- Ordered engineering inspections of river embankments and sluice gates.
- Deployed National Disaster Response Force (NDRF) and state civil defence units in flood-prone districts.
The West Bengal State Emergency Operation Centre (SEOC) continues to monitor river levels in real time using hydrological telemetry.
Official flood dashboard: India-WRIS Flood Monitoring Portal
Voices from the Ground
Residents in the Amta and Udaynarayanpur areas of Howrah district said they were caught unaware by the sudden surge in water.
“It happened in the middle of the night. We had no warning, no siren, nothing. Within hours, the water entered our houses,” said Sushmita Das, a local resident.
Farmers in Burdwan echoed similar frustrations, urging better warning systems and local-level coordination between DVC and gram panchayats.
Community groups and NGOs have called for a public flood alert system via SMS and radio for all villages along the Damodar and its tributaries.
Institutional Lessons and Federal Implications
The latest controversy underscores the fragility of centre–state coordination in federal infrastructure governance.
Water, while a state subject under the Constitution, involves shared management where interstate rivers are concerned.
Experts argue for a real-time joint command centre linking the DVC, state irrigation departments, and Central Water Commission for data sharing and flood forecasting.
The Way Forward: What Needs to Change
- Institutionalized Early Warning Mechanisms
Real-time hydrological data should be made public on transparent dashboards. - River Capacity Restoration
Accelerated dredging and sediment management along the Damodar, Mundeswari, and Rupnarayan rivers. - Floodplain Regulation
Strict enforcement against encroachments and unplanned construction on flood-prone lands. - Public Engagement and Education
Awareness programs on flood preparedness for communities along vulnerable basins. - State–Centre Coordination Protocols
Legal frameworks mandating advance intimation and joint decision-making on dam releases.
Conclusion: A Wake-Up Call for Bengal’s River Governance
The Damodar Valley Corporation flood controversy is not just a question of administrative oversight—it is a reflection of deeper systemic failures in water management and federal cooperation.
As climate unpredictability intensifies and river systems grow more fragile, both state and central agencies must move beyond blame games toward coordinated resilience-building.
Bengal’s recurrent struggles with floods, despite decades of planning, show that infrastructure without communication is infrastructure without security.
The people affected this Durga Puja deserve more than sympathy—they deserve a transparent, accountable system that values safety as much as sovereignty.
Also read: Home | Channel 6 Network – Latest News, Breaking Updates: Politics, Business, Tech & More
