Japanese Scholar Dies – What began as a scholarly visit to Kolkata by a respected Japanese academic ended in tragedy and silence. Micihihiro Kata, a 75-year-old scholar and writer from Japan, passed away after spending 12 days in the ICU of Medical College Hospital Kolkata (MCH), following a month-long battle for life that exposed the severe vulnerabilities faced by foreign nationals navigating India’s medical system without local support.
Kata had arrived in Kolkata in May to attend and speak at a seminar organized by the J. Krishnamurti Foundation (JKF). Known for his writings and deep intellectual pursuits, he had previously been involved with similar international academic platforms. However, in late June, during the event, he fell seriously ill, and what followed was a slow and painful descent marked by medical complications, language barriers, bureaucratic delays, and a startling absence of coordinated support.
Initial Hospitalization and Deterioration
On June 25, Kata was admitted to Manipal Hospital Dhakuria, one of the city’s well-known private hospitals. Doctors quickly diagnosed renal failure, accompanied by a severe E. coli infection. Over the next month, he underwent dialysis, blood transfusions, endoscopy, and advanced imaging, including a CT scan of the abdomen.
Medical records noted gastric complications—specifically, narrowing of the duodenum likely due to a possible tumor, and a metallic stent from a previous procedure that had moved dangerously close to the bile duct. His condition continued to worsen, with persistently low hemoglobin and episodes of dehydration.
Despite the best efforts of the doctors, Kata’s condition became precarious. But the medical challenges were only part of the crisis. The bigger issue was financial—and bureaucratic.
No Help from Home or Consulate
As his hospital bills mounted and his ability to stay in a private facility diminished, hospital authorities and JKF officials attempted to contact the Japanese Consulate in Kolkata, Japanese Embassy in New Delhi, and other relevant agencies in both countries.
To their shock, no family member, government body, or academic institution in Japan stepped forward to take responsibility or offer financial or logistical support for Kata’s ongoing treatment.
Manipal Hospital officials, left with no option, approached the West Bengal Clinical Establishment Regulatory Commission (WBCERC). After obtaining necessary permissions, the hospital arranged to shift Kata to the state-run Medical College Hospital Kolkata (MCH) on July 24.
MCH Struggles with Communication and Care
Doctors at MCH immediately diagnosed advanced gastric cancer with metastases, indicating that the disease had already spread to multiple organs. A five-member medical board was constituted to monitor his treatment in the ICU.
Kata was placed on mechanical ventilation in his final days. Despite the hospital’s efforts, his condition continued to decline.
Hospital authorities struggled with another issue—language and cultural barriers. Kata did not speak English, Hindi, or Bengali. Staff found it difficult to communicate with him. He often refused hospital food, unfamiliar with the Indian diet. Except for intravenous fluids and the occasional acceptance of soft food, his nutritional intake remained minimal.
Only once did he show signs of contentment—when an official from the Japanese consulate visited him and brought a Japanese meal. It was a brief, emotional moment of comfort in an otherwise isolating hospital experience.
Japanese Scholar Dies: The Final Hours
On August 4, doctors placed him on mechanical ventilation as his organs began to fail. In the early hours of August 5, Micihihiro Kata passed away at MCH after 12 days in the ICU.
His death was recorded, and the hospital promptly notified the West Bengal Health Department (Swasthya Bhawan) and the Japanese Consulate. As of this report, the hospital awaits instructions on the formal handover of the body, as no next of kin or legal representative has yet responded.
A Crisis of Responsibility
The case has triggered deep introspection within the medical and diplomatic community in Kolkata. How does a well-respected foreign academic die in a state hospital with no consular follow-up, no family communication, and no official institutional support?
Dr. Anjan Adhikari, a senior professor at MCH and part of the medical team overseeing Kata’s case, said:
“His cancer was terminal when he came to us. We did everything within our capacity. But he had no attendant, no translator, no family… it was heartbreaking.”
A member of the MCH administration echoed similar frustration:
“We kept updating the authorities, but there was no real plan from the consulate or the foundation. We were left managing a dying man who couldn’t even express his pain to us.”
Did Institutions Fail Him?
The J. Krishnamurti Foundation (India), though instrumental in inviting Kata, clarified that it had no long-term logistical arrangement for his stay or medical care. The foundation’s local Kolkata chapter tried to support him emotionally and arranged some help, but lacked the infrastructure for prolonged medical assistance.
More questions are being raised about the role of the Japanese consular services. While a consulate official did visit him briefly, there appears to have been no structured consular protection plan, no clear guidance for emergency evacuation, and no interpreter arranged despite the language barrier.
In a globalized world where scholars often travel for conferences, lectures, and research exchanges, this case lays bare the absence of protocols for medical emergencies involving foreign nationals, particularly the elderly.
Reactions from the Academic Community
Several academic voices across Kolkata have expressed grief and disbelief at the episode. A professor from Jadavpur University, who had interacted with Kata during his previous visit, noted:
“He was a gentle intellectual, deeply reflective, and respectful of Indian traditions. That he died like this—in silence, in isolation—is something we all should be ashamed of.”
There is a growing call among Indian academic and cultural organizations to include health emergency protocols and insurance requirements for all foreign invitees—particularly independent elderly scholars.
What Now?
As Kata’s body lies unclaimed, MCH waits for consular directives. Legally, a foreign national’s body cannot be cremated or buried without the respective country’s permission, which is typically relayed through the embassy.
The hospital has taken all steps necessary under Indian law, including sending written updates to Swasthya Bhawan and the Japanese Consulate. But the absence of any family response and the delay in official directions have left the hospital in a state of helplessness.
Need for Policy Overhaul
This episode reveals a glaring policy vacuum. Neither the Indian government nor foreign embassies seem to have a concrete framework for:
- Handling long-term hospitalization of foreign nationals
- Ensuring translators or cultural mediators in public hospitals
- Coordinating with NGOs or local support groups
- Rapidly responding to consular emergencies in state-run institutions
It’s a reminder that globalization is not just about borders and trade—but about real people with real needs. And in that, both sending and host countries must act responsibly.
External Links for Further Context
- J. Krishnamurti Foundation (India)
- Medical College Hospital Kolkata
- West Bengal Clinical Establishment Regulatory Commission
- Japanese Embassy in India – Consular Protection
Also read: Home | Channel 6 Network – Latest News, Breaking Updates: Politics, Business, Tech & More
