West Bengal Health Panel: The West Bengal Clinical Establishment Regulatory Commission (WBCERC) has recently issued a directive with far-reaching social and medical implications. Hospitals across the state have now been instructed to release the body of a deceased patient within five hours, regardless of whether medical dues are cleared or insurance claims are processed. The move aims to restore dignity in death, prevent unnecessary trauma to families, and ensure that healthcare institutions operate with a sense of compassion alongside financial discipline.
The Incident That Sparked the Directive
The commission’s decision was triggered by a disturbing case in Kolkata. A 74-year-old man passed away around midnight at a private hospital, but his body was withheld until the following afternoon due to pending insurance clearance. The patient’s family, already shattered by the loss, was forced to endure long hours of distress and helplessness.
Justice (Retd) Ashim Kumar Banerjee, the chairperson of the commission, called this withholding of a body “a grave violation of human rights” and declared that no patient or family should face such suffering. He emphasized that non-compliance would not be tolerated and that hospitals failing to follow the five-hour rule could face action.
The Human Angle: Why Timely Release Matters
For many communities, funeral and burial rituals are highly time-sensitive. Any delay not only prolongs grief but also interferes with cultural and religious practices. Families often feel dehumanized when financial or procedural hurdles overshadow the need to bid a respectful farewell.
This new directive, therefore, is not just about hospital administration—it touches on questions of human dignity, ethical medical practice, and the balance between compassion and commerce in healthcare.
Hospitals’ Concerns: Financial Security vs. Compliance
While most hospital administrators have welcomed the spirit of the order, they have raised concerns about its practical and financial implications. Private healthcare is a costly enterprise, and institutions worry that releasing bodies without settlement of dues could open the door to exploitation.
Hospital representatives have suggested alternatives such as:
- Allowing families to sign undertakings or surety bonds promising payment.
- Establishing clear legal safeguards to ensure hospitals are not financially burdened.
- Developing a fast-track insurance clearance system so that disputes are minimized.
According to healthcare administrators, the directive is humane, but it must not destabilize the functioning of hospitals that already struggle with delayed insurance payments and rising operational costs.
West Bengal Health Panel: Learning from Other States
The issue of hospitals withholding bodies is not unique to West Bengal. In Assam, the government introduced a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) mandating that bodies be released within two hours of death certification. Families can lodge complaints through a 24×7 helpline, and hospitals face penalties ranging from heavy fines to suspension of licenses for non-compliance.
Such precedents indicate that states across India are moving toward patient- and family-centric healthcare regulation, placing humanity above red tape.
The Broader Ethical and Legal Debate
The new directive raises important questions:
- Should financial dues override human dignity? Critics argue that hospitals sometimes use bodies as leverage to extract payments.
- What safeguards can balance compassion with accountability? Hospitals need assurance that dues will eventually be settled, while families deserve immediate access to the bodies of their loved ones.
- Can insurance procedures be reformed? One recurring issue is that insurance claims, especially through Third-Party Administrators (TPAs), often take hours—or even days—to process. A simplified, tech-enabled system could address this bottleneck.
Policy Recommendations Going Forward
Experts suggest a three-pronged approach:
- Legal Clarity – Hospitals should be given the right to pursue unpaid bills through civil mechanisms, rather than withholding bodies.
- Insurance Reforms – TPAs and insurance firms should have dedicated 24×7 emergency approval cells.
- Public Awareness – Families must know their rights. Helplines and grievance redressal platforms should be promoted across West Bengal.
Cultural and Religious Dimensions
In Bengal, as in much of India, last rites hold deep cultural and spiritual significance. Whether it is Hindu cremation rituals performed within a day of death or Muslim burials typically completed within 24 hours, any delay is not only painful but also sacrilegious to families. The directive therefore restores not just dignity, but also religious freedom and cultural respect.
Conclusion: A Step Toward Humane Healthcare
The West Bengal health panel’s five-hour rule represents a compassionate attempt to ensure death is treated with the dignity it deserves. It sets a precedent for other states to follow and underscores that hospitals, while justified in seeking their dues, cannot hold grieving families hostage.
Yet, for the order to succeed, it must be backed by policy innovation, legal safeguards, and insurance reforms. Only then can the healthcare system balance its dual responsibility—compassion for patients and families, and sustainability for institutions.
External References for Context
- World Health Organization – Patient Rights and Healthcare Ethics
- NITI Aayog Report on India’s Healthcare Challenges
- Medical Council of India – Code of Ethics Regulations
Also read: Home | Channel 6 Network – Latest News, Breaking Updates: Politics, Business, Tech & More
